I printed it with "rope" font, although its kind of hard to tell. I decided that I didn't like it on white, so I re-printed it on red cardstock.
Then, I took my paper cutter and trimmed it down so that it was just about half an inch smaller than the black cardstock, all the way around.
I punched the eyelets at all four corners. This took a little more force because it had to pierce through two layers of cardstock.